- Patrick Bellinger – Evansville
- Connor Bieda – Alvin College (TX)
- Ryan Czachor – Phoenix College/Oakton
- Aaron DeGeorge – McHenry
- Mike DeRosa – Cornell College
- Erik Fetchko – Purdue North Central
- Jack Forde – DePauw University
- Jimmy Frankos – Iowa
- Matt Godinsky – Grinell
- Nick Johnson – Benedictine University
- Alex Hernandez – Dominican University
- C. Illiopoulos – Spoon River College/Truman State
- Charlie Jerger – Heartland/Northern Kentucky
- Brent Kiesel – Harper College
- Derrick Mason – McHenry
- Jake Monson – Aurora U.
- Ryan Ross – North Central
- Bryce Skelton – Lakeland
- Kevin Stahmer – Cornell
- Frank Walkiczek – Heartland
